With support from the opposition Conservatives, the Liberal government is steamrolling Bill C-5, a bill of enormous consequence that will not get the serious scrutiny it deserves.
Those who could be consulted won't "drag their feet." They realize the need for persistently moving forward. But, for heaven's sake, let's do it right and come out on the other side with a TERRIFIC bill, not one that invites endless unhappiness for those whose rights are ignored instead of being held high, revered and cherished. We can do all of that in timely fashion. As Canadians we know we must!
Bill C-5 is a huge disappointment from a government progressives rallied behind as the only choice. Now it is the Conservatives' support that is enabling the bill to be passed. It doesn't bode well for our future. I hope this is not a"goodbye" Alex, and only a summer break; we need your insight.
Thank you for your rigorous efforts to bring out the truths we need to hear. I am so disappointed with the Carney government for ramming through this frightening bill. The results will be catastrophic for Indigenous people and for all Canadians. I hope you will have a good break from you labours and be back in the fall to keep us informed about things no one else is talking about.
What are the interests who are pushing things like Bill C5 in Ontario and Bill C5 federally? Why do upright citizens we have elected to defend essential interests of Canadians turn out to be, once elected, at the beck and call of craven interests that will costs dearly in time, money, reputation, integrity? I do hope that Pledge for Canada will be back. You have provided a breath of sanity and strengthened my spine to stand for what is right for the community rather than individuals. Thank you. Have a great summer. Au revoir! Bruna
I recognize my need for informed and educated insights into what our country is experiencing. For that I thank you and wish you a "speedy recovery". I will stay tuned...
An excessive lack of consultation alround with this bill. A nightmare that it comes in cohort with Ontario's similar bill. A banker taking all his info from business people who would benefit from the result. It is certainly Trump-like in its sloppy approach. No forethought to the future and how other prime ministers and their sidekicks would bend this legislation to bring fascism to Canada. There is a strong whiff of dictatorial approach with the rapid deadlines. Major projects can be done in a timely manner if they are carefully planned and focus on goals, such as environmentally forward thinking. Why is it that Scandinavian countries, who have 50 and 60 years of experience in sound environmental projects be tapped for ideas? And although our cabinet and House, when taken as a whole, have an average IQ higher than the cabinet and house in the U S there is a definite problem with a laisez fare approach by staff to not be thorough. The fact that neither Mr Carney nor his staff knew right from the get go that indigenous players had to be involved is a glaring error. The fact that he spoke to heads of multiple foreign countries before even speaking to all heads of all the other parties in his own country speaks poorly of him personally, and surprised me. Seems like he is too tightly in his own silo and not willing to take on nonmonetary awareness of social issues. The banking sector wins no awards for placing the good of society above profits. Canadians chose a professional economist with great hope for clearheadedness, professionalism, and a commitment to our long fought for ideals. But it looks like shortsightedness and an inability to include sufficient input from all corners, sectors, vast research resources and cultural groups, will merely set us on the path to a fascist decline of our own in the years ahead. No, I do not make this comment lightly.
More haste, less speed: a well-reasoned critique of the rush to pass this bill. Why do people with power get so quickly drunk on it? We all know what drunk driving leaves behind.
Would love more exploration and discussion by The Pledge around more Direct Democracy as Represenative Democracy is clearly losing its credibility. It was the best of governance systems for centuries, but now we finally have the (digital) capability for more Direct Democracy and gradually eliminating the need for the "middle man".
Imagine a world without liberal or conservative... right or left. Just everyone directly providing input to policy development.
I'm relieved that you have no plans to abandon this effort... but I know how tough it is to realize the headwinds are so strong that we may actually go backwards. ... I'm reminded of Et la lumière fut/And there was Light by Jacques Lusseyran, the "blind hero of the French resistance".
Friends and I are working to help people realize UCD (Unarmed Civilian Defence) makes more sense than squandering billions (so many resources!) on weapons. UCD is not just about resisting outside "enemies" but totally about building our capacity to resist tyranny in all its forms. If you would have time to explore this in a zoom discussion with us that would be a gift! janslakov @ proton.me
Thanks so much for all you have done. At times like these, leadership like yours is invaluable. Bill C-5 is indeed a travesty, a reminder that we need to be vigilant inside our national boundaries as well as beyond them. Have a great break, it is well-deserved.
Those who could be consulted won't "drag their feet." They realize the need for persistently moving forward. But, for heaven's sake, let's do it right and come out on the other side with a TERRIFIC bill, not one that invites endless unhappiness for those whose rights are ignored instead of being held high, revered and cherished. We can do all of that in timely fashion. As Canadians we know we must!
absolutely
I have appreciated your articles and the perspective it provides. Enjoy your break. Hope you do return.
thanks Denis
Bill C-5 is a huge disappointment from a government progressives rallied behind as the only choice. Now it is the Conservatives' support that is enabling the bill to be passed. It doesn't bode well for our future. I hope this is not a"goodbye" Alex, and only a summer break; we need your insight.
Thanks Rebecca, Craig and I are exploring how best to contribute. I appreciate your generous comment - a lot.
So disappointed in Mark Carney...this is the same old neoliberal private-sector-led development on steroids
Thank you for your rigorous efforts to bring out the truths we need to hear. I am so disappointed with the Carney government for ramming through this frightening bill. The results will be catastrophic for Indigenous people and for all Canadians. I hope you will have a good break from you labours and be back in the fall to keep us informed about things no one else is talking about.
Thanks Patricia.
What are the interests who are pushing things like Bill C5 in Ontario and Bill C5 federally? Why do upright citizens we have elected to defend essential interests of Canadians turn out to be, once elected, at the beck and call of craven interests that will costs dearly in time, money, reputation, integrity? I do hope that Pledge for Canada will be back. You have provided a breath of sanity and strengthened my spine to stand for what is right for the community rather than individuals. Thank you. Have a great summer. Au revoir! Bruna
yes! so we continue to speak out one way or another
Thank you for your service. We Canadians need information and strategies to hold on to our stated values.
thanks jf
Thank you for your ideas, your thoughtfulness and your obvious unbridled enthusiasm for a stronger Canada that serves the people of Canada.
Thank you. We love Social Capital Partners!
Where's that warm, fuzzy emoji?
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRVp0zSmqeimtCDbT1_d0NFAtbroXCJTyG7grLCBk4GmA&s
I recognize my need for informed and educated insights into what our country is experiencing. For that I thank you and wish you a "speedy recovery". I will stay tuned...
Ha. Thanks Rae.
An excessive lack of consultation alround with this bill. A nightmare that it comes in cohort with Ontario's similar bill. A banker taking all his info from business people who would benefit from the result. It is certainly Trump-like in its sloppy approach. No forethought to the future and how other prime ministers and their sidekicks would bend this legislation to bring fascism to Canada. There is a strong whiff of dictatorial approach with the rapid deadlines. Major projects can be done in a timely manner if they are carefully planned and focus on goals, such as environmentally forward thinking. Why is it that Scandinavian countries, who have 50 and 60 years of experience in sound environmental projects be tapped for ideas? And although our cabinet and House, when taken as a whole, have an average IQ higher than the cabinet and house in the U S there is a definite problem with a laisez fare approach by staff to not be thorough. The fact that neither Mr Carney nor his staff knew right from the get go that indigenous players had to be involved is a glaring error. The fact that he spoke to heads of multiple foreign countries before even speaking to all heads of all the other parties in his own country speaks poorly of him personally, and surprised me. Seems like he is too tightly in his own silo and not willing to take on nonmonetary awareness of social issues. The banking sector wins no awards for placing the good of society above profits. Canadians chose a professional economist with great hope for clearheadedness, professionalism, and a commitment to our long fought for ideals. But it looks like shortsightedness and an inability to include sufficient input from all corners, sectors, vast research resources and cultural groups, will merely set us on the path to a fascist decline of our own in the years ahead. No, I do not make this comment lightly.
Thanks for this Sandra.
Very sad to see what is unfolding in Ottawa - but entirely predictable. Hope Charlie Angus can lead us in the Resistance
More haste, less speed: a well-reasoned critique of the rush to pass this bill. Why do people with power get so quickly drunk on it? We all know what drunk driving leaves behind.
exactly
Would love more exploration and discussion by The Pledge around more Direct Democracy as Represenative Democracy is clearly losing its credibility. It was the best of governance systems for centuries, but now we finally have the (digital) capability for more Direct Democracy and gradually eliminating the need for the "middle man".
Imagine a world without liberal or conservative... right or left. Just everyone directly providing input to policy development.
Great idea. My friend Peter Macleod is just finishing a book on this. You might find this by him interesting https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gzEewrKc6NCf4O7v5NZ35VI6pJwUmsZXRjjr2I0dbhM/mobilebasic
I'm relieved that you have no plans to abandon this effort... but I know how tough it is to realize the headwinds are so strong that we may actually go backwards. ... I'm reminded of Et la lumière fut/And there was Light by Jacques Lusseyran, the "blind hero of the French resistance".
Friends and I are working to help people realize UCD (Unarmed Civilian Defence) makes more sense than squandering billions (so many resources!) on weapons. UCD is not just about resisting outside "enemies" but totally about building our capacity to resist tyranny in all its forms. If you would have time to explore this in a zoom discussion with us that would be a gift! janslakov @ proton.me
sure - let’s
Thanks so much for all you have done. At times like these, leadership like yours is invaluable. Bill C-5 is indeed a travesty, a reminder that we need to be vigilant inside our national boundaries as well as beyond them. Have a great break, it is well-deserved.
Thanks so much Susan!
I've just written to both my MP and PM Carney using the above info and other opinions on Bill C2.
Good stuff Ratz!